Grammy Chairman Responds to Task Force Demands: 'We Must Take Action'

Ahead of the 62nd annual , the Chairman and interim CEO of the Recording Academy Harvey Mason Jr. responded to demands made by the Diversity Task Force for “real and constructive change.”

Signed by a mix of artists and task force members, the Tina Tchen-chaired committee, which was created in February 2018 “to take a hard, independent look” at the organization and its role in the music industry, released a statement on Thursday criticizing the Recording Academy for dragging its feet in implementing its 18 recommendations within the organization.

“Since I took office, we as an organization have agreed to do 17 of those 18 recommendations. I know some will feel that we’re not doing enough fast enough. I understand the urgency. For me personally, and for this organization, these immediate steps are a continuation of our ongoing work,” Mason Jr. said in his statement to Recording Academy members.

On Sunday, he announced a series of new initiatives developed in partnership with the Diversity Task Force, including the hiring of a dedicated Diversity & Inclusion Officer within the next 90 days, an Academy-funded fellowship responsible for the “independent review and reporting of the progress of the Academy’s Diversity & Inclusion efforts” in the next 120 days, a fund to be given yearly to different “women in music” organizations—effective immediately—and a “deeper exploration” of the 18 Task Force recommendations that will include the voting processes for the Grammys.

“We must take action. There is no excuse for waiting, especially when so many of our members have been tirelessly advocating for a bold new direction for so long,” added Mason Jr.

The Recording Academy Chairman’s statement follows news of Grammys CEO being put on administrative leave just 10 days before this year’s ceremony. With regards to the suspension, The Recording Academy board of trustees revealed there was “a formal allegation of misconduct by a senior female member of the Recording Academy team” that led to it.

But on January 21st, Dugan responded to the ouster filing a discrimination complaint with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) against the Recording Academy, where she claimed that former Grammys CEO Portnow had raped a female recording artist. Portnow has since denied the allegations in a statement, describing them as “ludicrous and untrue.” In her lawsuit, Dugan also made allegations against Recording Academy attorney Joel Katz for sexually harassing her. In an interview on Good Morning America, Dugan further elaborated on her alleged experiences with the Recording Academy’s “boys club,” the voting irregularities at the Grammys and her desire to execute change with her role.

“I wanted to make change from within,” she said. “I moved across the country, I had a great job, I believe in what the Recording Academy should stand for—for artists. I was trying at each step to say, ‘OK, I can make a difference, I can fix this, I can work with this team.’”

While Dugan’s name isn’t mentioned in the Mason Jr.’s new statement, he addressed the “challenging week” the Academy experienced.

“I’ve heard from many of you who feel betrayed and hurt by the untruths being spread about our motives and actions, the integrity of our process and the artists who’ve rightfully earned their Grammy nominations, and the reminders of the hard truths we do have to face as a community. We can all be proud that we are recommitting ourselves to transparency, to independent investigations, and to following the facts wherever they lead,” he said.

Dugan’s lawyers Douglas H. Wigdor and Michael J. Willemin, issued a statement Sunday in response to Mason Jr.’s letter to the Recording Academy.

“Harvey Mason’s public statement on the eve of the Grammys is all smoke and mirrors given that each of his so called new ‘initiatives’ had already been agreed to under the direction of Ms. Dugan,’ Dugan’s counsel wrote.

“If the past ten days have shown anything, it is that the current Chair is not the appropriate individual to effectuate meaningful change at the Academy.  This is the same Chair that put Ms. Dugan on leave because she was calling for increased diversity and the end to self-dealing and conflicts of interest.  This is the same Chair that has leaked attack after attack on Ms. Dugan to the media, and done everything in his power to defame and disparage her.  In fact, in the very same statement that Mr. Mason just issued calling for change, he makes additional attacks against Ms. Dugan.  The prior male CEO was not even put on leave when he was alleged to have raped a woman.  Yet, Ms. Dugan remains on leave to this day.” 

Wigdor and Willemin then outlined how “four things must happen immediately” in order to exact “real change” in the Recording Academy.

“First, there must be an independent and qualified professional Chair and Board,” they wrote. “Second, the Academy must agree to immediately suspend the conflict-rife nominating review committees (‘secret committees’).  Third, there must be a truly independent investigation into the Board’s relationships, self-dealings, and use of public non-profit monies.  Finally, the Board must immediately reinstate Ms. Dugan as the CEO of the Recording Academy to oversee and effectuate such changes.”

Read Mason Jr.’s entire statement below:

Six months ago, when I put my hat in the ring to be your Chair, I did so because I believed that the Academy could do better – could be better. The music we create has always reflected the best of ourselves and our world. But what was true of music has historically not been true of the music business as a whole. Too often, our industry and Academy have alienated some of our own artists – in particular, through a lack of diversity that, in many cases, results in a culture that leans towards exclusion rather than inclusion.

The Academy is recognized for our excellence. We are a leader. And being a leader means taking responsibility even when it feels like the problems at hand are bigger than us.

This is hard. Some might feel that responsibility is unfair, while others might feel it’s not going far enough. But in the end, we must take on this work. Because it’s the right thing to do.

I ran for this position because, as a music creator, I wanted to help bring this organization in line with the values I know this community shares. I asked for your trust – and your help – as we continue to push the Academy towards a place where everyone is valued, respected, and included. That’s the Academy that we – artists and fans alike – deserve.

In entering this role six months ago, I was fortunate to be building on courageous and inspiring work. Artists – especially women and artists of color – had long begun demanding transparency and taking on our traditional power structure. They have found allies across the industry who believe that we can do better and have joined the fight for change.

In February 2018, we empowered a Diversity Task Force, led by Tina Tchen and made up of distinguished individuals from outside the Academy, to take a hard, independent look at our organization specifically and the music industry as a whole. They detailed the ways in which we were falling short, and laid out 18 recommendations for change.

Since I took office, we as an organization have agreed to 17 of those 18 recommendations. I know some will feel that we’re not doing enough fast enough. I understand the urgency. For me personally, and for this organization, these immediate steps are a continuation of our ongoing work.

But it’s not enough to pledge ourselves to change. We must take action. There is no excuse for waiting, especially when so many of our members have been tirelessly advocating for a bold new direction for so long.

That’s why I’m proud to announce these new initiatives, initiatives developed in partnership with the Diversity Task Force and other champions of change. They include the following:

1. The Academy will hire a dedicated Diversity & Inclusion Officer. This person will be hired within the next 90 days.

2. We will establish a fellowship, funded by the Academy, that will be responsible for independent review and reporting of the progress of the Academy’s Diversity & Inclusion efforts. This will be in place within 120 days.

3. We will create a fund to be distributed annually to different “women in music” organizations that will be managed by the D&I Officer. This will go into effect immediately.

4. The Academy will recommit to meeting all 18 of the Task Force Recommendations as outlined in the full report and in a manner that will endure, with the caveat that we will have a deeper exploration, along with the Task Force into voting processes for the GRAMMYS.

5. We are committing to meet with the Task Force to review our progress on these as well as the rest of their eighteen initiatives. This first meeting will happen in 45 days. There will be subsequent follow ups to review progress.

It’s been a challenging week for our Academy family. I’ve heard from many of you who feel betrayed and hurt by the untruths being spread about our motives and actions, the integrity of our process and the artists who’ve rightfully earned their GRAMMY Nominations, and the reminders of the hard truths we do have to face as a community. We can all be proud that we are recommitting ourselves to transparency, to independent investigations, and to following the facts wherever they lead. And I want to thank the incredible Academy team that, through it all, work day and night, from staff, artist support services, member relations, chapter leaders, MusiCares, The GRAMMY Museum and Foundation, and to those putting on a spectacular show and the week’s events.

The movement to ensure that the Academy – and the music business – is truly representative of artists and their audiences has been going on for a long time. And that struggle will continue, not just for women and people of color, but for members of the LGBTQ+ community, for artists struggling to make ends meet, for those suffering from addiction or mental health challenges, for people of all shapes and sizes and backgrounds, and for groups we may not even recognize today. As a leading voice in the industry, we have an obligation to be on the frontlines of that change. To build a system that continuously evolves with our changing society – a system where every artist, no matter who they are, feels welcomed and supported. That’s what it will take to not just survive but thrive in an industry that’s transforming as quickly as ours.

This won’t be easy. But here’s the thing: I know we can do this together. Because that’s what we have always done. We are collaborators. After all, as a peer-based community, the Academy truly represents music at its best. It has always reflected the very artists who grapple with the issues that shape our times, and push society to live up to our ideals. That’s what it means to be a part of this extraordinary community of artists – people with integrity, people with passion, and people who, above all, are committed to music and its possibilities.

Tonight, many of our colleagues will take the stage on Music’s Biggest Night, be honored by their community of peers and thank the Academy. On behalf of the Academy, I’d like to thank them. Thank you for the authenticity you bring to your craft, the dignity with which you carry yourselves, and the love you show to each other and our world.

I look forward to working side by side with you to continue building an Academy that reflects the best in us, and honors the incredible artists who lift us up every day.

Respectfully Yours,

Harvey Mason Jr